Photo by Thobekile Zwane
from 2014 PhotoXP visual project
Live in Ventersdorp
More to be included…
On the 19th Aug. 2014, Inkanyiso members visited the home of the recent victim of hate crime, Gift Disebo Makau in Ventersdorp.
Her dead body was discovered directly opposite her mother’s home, 70 metres away.
She was a young ‘out’ lesbian well known in the community.
A good soccer player and played for Mighty Ladies.
Her mother accepted her sexuality and love Disebo dearly.
Her sister will always missed her beautiful smile…
Disebo’s mother, MaMakau shows the ID book of her deceased daughter.
She is survived by her sister Rinah, left, mother and brother Tshepang…
The beautiful portrait of a youngster who had dreams and hope of becoming an accountant… She attended her higher at Vuselela FET College at the time of her death…
She was last seen by her mother on Thurs, 14th Aug. 2014.
A candle is lit as part of the mourning ritual…
Ventersdorp community is enraged by the brutal killing of Disebo Makau.
The residents gathered at the stadium to discuss the escalating crime in the areas… A meeting was convened by the local councillor…
A piece of this hose pipe was rammed into her throat…
Her lower body naked, it is allegedly that she was raped before being killed…
Ward Councillor Mapule Mataboge addresses the residents of Ventersdorp about the incident…
Rinah Makau, sits on Disebo’s bed… thinking about her.
The crime scene in front of her mother’s home.
Hose pipe which was forced into her mouth with running water. Part of it will be used for evidence in court…
Disebo’s cellphone which was discovered at the alleged suspect’s home.
Photos by Zanele Muholi
My name is Sphiwe Sesana Mbatha. I am a very funny person, I love people and I love happy endings. I am a very dedicated when it comes to work, and I’m a fast learner too.
I am ambitious and always ready to face the challenges that come my way. I was born at Boksburg Hospital on the 14th November 1992.
At home we speak isiZulu and I can also speak Sotho, English and a bit of Xhosa. I have a mother and a father and I have a little brother.
I live in Daveyton, with my grandmother, four aunts, five siblings, two uncles, and my mother. However my mother is always away because of her work.
I am unemployed, I am still hustling for a job. I went to Intuthuko day care centre, and a year after I started school at Kuzimisela Primary School, from standard one until standard five.
I enjoyed my primary school because I was active in sports especially in soccer and athletics. My grandmother had a small business, selling beers at home in order for us to survive. My father deserted me, he refused to take responsibility.
In 2006 I went to study at H.B Nyathi Secondary School from standard 6 until standard 10. I passed my matric with symbol B and went to further my studies at MSC Business College.
I was studying (IT) Information Technology but I had to drop out because of financial problems at home.
I want to be an IT Specialist, I would love to go back to college and finish up my course. I want to improve technology all over the world. I want to make world a better place, turn negative situations into positives. I like playing soccer and dancing.
I am a proud lesbian woman and I identify myself as a woman who is sexually and physically attracted to same sex gender. In 2012 I entered Mr and Mrs Lesbian Uthingo, Daveyton and I was the 1st prince.
In 2013 I entered Mr Lesbian Daveyton and I took a second prince position. I am a butch and masculine. I am not a lesbian by choice, it is because I am attracted to other women.
Being lesbian means a lot to me, especially being in an open closet, some lesbians who are in the closet wish to be like me.
They wish to have freedom like me, but they cant because of their families. I love the fact that as a lesbian couple, you get to talk about everything in your relationship because, you both females and you understand each other.
I won’t say my family is happy or sad about me being lesbian, they accepted me and they never gave me problems about my sexuality. I grew up mostly with boys, acting boyish since I was young and I never loved girls’ clothes.
I can say I was an open book since I was young. I’m in a relationship with a female, my family is still not aware about our relationship because its still early days and we not staying together, she lives with her family and I live with mine.
We are willing to make things work between us because she makes me happy. We all deserve to be loved and everyone deserves to be happy.
Last year September I dated a girl from Soweto, it was a long distance relationship and then early February I found the girl I loved for a very long time.
We got in a relationship and I decided to end the other relationship with the Soweto girl. After a few days the Soweto girl started stalking us, insulting us on facebook, smsses, whatsapp even calling us ten times a day just to insult us.
When she heard that we broke up, she was the first to celebrate. She’s making my life a living hell because she’s still insulting me, my family and friends especially my mom and grandmom.
I don’t know why she’s involving my family and friends. Everyday I receive 18 massages from her insulting me and my family and she makes sure my relationships don’t last.
This girl is making my life miserable.
We cannot stop hate crimes but we can prevent it. We have to educate people about the lgbti community and make them see that we are also people and we deserve to be treated like human beings.
If I were to be a leader or tv presenter I would focus on talking about traditional norms that we have to break because other lgbti people cannot follow them.
I will also focus on Gender Based Violence (GBV). I would like to go back to school, finish my IT course, graduate, and have a well paying job.
I would use the chance wisely so that I can benefit in future. The true meaning of my identity means being a daughter to my mom and a sister to my brother. I was once attacked by a group of boys.
I was coming from the shops around 8pm, they hit me with a iron on my left knee, searched my pockets and took my new phone, before they left one of the guys said ”stabane ndini uzofa mawungazibhekanga” I was shocked and scared to tell my parents.
From that day I learnt to be very careful because bad luck has its ways to come.
Being part of Faces & Phases is a great experience. I remember my friend took me to Zanele Muholi’s exhibition and I loved her work. I then told my friend that I would also love to be part of the project. Muholi took us for a photo shoot and I enjoyed every minute of it. I felt like a star and I was happy to be given the opportunity because I love being a model.
I enjoy working with Muholi, she’s caring and I respect her so much. I thank her for giving me such a great opportunity to make something for my life as a young female lesbian.
Previous life stories
2014 July 26: “I was born this way and I cannot change the skin that I live in”
and
2014 June 25: I consider myself beautiful not handsome…
and
and
2014 May 7: I don’t like being identified in terms and definitions
and
2014 May 18: Behind the beautiful face you see is a lesbian who is torn into a million pieces
and
2014 May 30: I was a boy who would one day grow up to be a man
and
2013 Oct. 22: I thought university was for the rich
and
2013 Oct. 16: I am a beautiful young dyke, a woman lover
and
2013 Oct. 12: I just feel she deserves much better
and
2013 Oct. 2: I am a normal transgender woman’
and
2013 Aug. 22: Am exactly where I’m supposed to be
and
2013 July 15: The virus has become a silent relative
and
and
2013 March 10: “I love women and they love me”
and
2013 February 28: I am not a Victim but a Victor
A two-day workshop aimed at developing LGBTI-ally support, and advocacy network, is hosted by the US Embassy and GALA at the University of Witwatersrand in Johannesburg.
The event started on August 11 and is facilitated by Jody Huckaby who is the executive director of the US based organisation called Parents, Families, and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG).
Senate House at Wits accommodated parents of children identifying under the LGBTI umbrella and some attended with their children.
Other members of the public who wanted to learn more about challenges facing the LGBTI community also participated in the workshop.
Attendees traveled from various Ekurhuleni townships and other parts of Johannesburg including Soweto.
Jody explained to the group that an ally is someone wiling to take a look at the unique challenges of lgbtis. He added that allies also have the task of coming out as allies and must be willing to learn more.
One parent Linda Mankazana said having a lesbian daughter she hoped the workshop would aid her when it comes to communicate with her daughter. She said although she is free and talks freely with her daughter’s friends who are in the lgbti community they have not discussed her daughter’s own sexual orientation.
Linda said as a school teacher, she wants to acquire more information.
While Mally Simelane who lost her daughter Eudy Simelane in a 2008 murder, described by many as a hate crime because she was lesbian.
Mally is still active in the lgbti community and has a support group that educates parents from her church about lgbti issues.
“I am educating fellow mothers to eradicate homophobia in homes and avoid children being disowned by their parents,” said Mally.
Lerato Nthupi, Buyisiwe Mashinini, Thelma Masimini and Nomvula Mkhwanazi said they are part of the South African Council of Churches (SACC) and members of the support group driven by Mally.
They said although all their children identify as heterosexuals, they are supportive of Mally and LGBTI matters and came to the workshop to gain more knowledge.
One supportive mother asked to remain anonymous for fear of a backlash from her family if they found out she is attending LGBTI events with her lesbian daughter.
“The LGBTI community is demonised, and I’m afraid that if I don’t support my child she will end up feeling alone and with no sense of belonging,” added the mother.
Photographer, Zanele Muholi inquired if it was necessary for South African activists and organisations to rely on international support instead of assisting one another.
Muholi pointed to the legislative gains such as marriage and adoption rights made by the LGBTI community in South Africa and urged local stake holders to forge closer ties and collaborations.
The visual activist said holding such workshops at Universities limits the access of many people, adding that more people need to be reached across South Africa.
Chad Wesen a Political Officer for Human Rights said PFLAG’s visit to South Africa is part of a US programme.
He said it stems from a need expressed by SA activists and the intention is to identify how the US experience could benefit SA.
Chad said media and family issues were identified by SA activists as areas that South Africa still lacked when it comes to lgbti issues.
2014 Aug. 11: My experiences of Paris, Mpumalanga and Durban Gay Pride
by Luh Cele
My perseverance and the love of the game once upon a time resulted in a progressive life of meeting interesting people and travel abroad. In this note I’d like to share share my lifetime experiences, of pride marches with hopes that other LGBTI people will one day have a chance to explore such events.
I have extended my experience based on the same calibre events from globally, provincial and locally. In 2012 we went to Paris-France march known as Marche des Fiertes LGBT and recently we were in Mpumalanga on August 9, 2014 after attending the Durban Pride in June 2014.
Activists and LGBTI members came out in numbers to participate in the first Mpumalanga Pride, Nelspruit
In Paris-France we as “Thokozani Football Club” blended well with the event. We were so excited, highly active and performing our local songs and dancing. The team spirit was highly noted and appreciated, remembering the energy of soccer players and marching for our fellow activists who have lost their lives for simply being who they are and for “coming out”.
We were singing with the purpose of sending the message throughout the world begging people to stop killing LGBTI individuals. Paris is a country which is very free from violation of rights of the LGBTI than African countries. The pride march was well organised, and always starts at Tour Montparnasse and ends at Place de la Bastille,while the route is closed for the whole day, to accommodate the event.
We were marching together with lots of banners and LGBTI flags. The one written by Thokozani Football Club read as: “We are the South African Rainbow Nation marching for those who cannot and are unable to be here today, stop hate crime, corrective rape and killing LGBTI”. The setting was extremely excellent, the attendance consisted of thousands of people who were not only homosexuals.
Moreover, the awareness has been totally created in overseas countries we are also praying for the same in South African countries, where the is high stigmatization of LGBTI people.
The Lowveld, Emalahleni and Glom LGBTI, launched their first Mpumalanga March Pride. It coincided with the very acknowledged, National Women’s Day, on August 9. The day commemorates the march held in 1956, at the Union Buildings in Pretoria. The event challenged the legislation which was stipulated during apartheid era that Black South Africans should carry their pass books in all their movements.
We were fortunate to attend Mpumalanga Pride which was reasonably attended by the LGBTI community from different provinces and local townships around SA. The nature of the setting was similar to other events.
It started from SABC offices to the Nelspruit Plaza and ended up at Mpumalanga show grounds. However the was interrupts when it went to the Plaza and not in a place where it was going to be ended at.
After a few hours standing at the plaza, residents were surprised not knowing what was happening exactly. I quote a woman who was walking in the plaza asking another woman “what is happening now with the gays” the other woman answered “I don’t know”. People realised that there was some kind of an event for LGBTI but the elderly couldn’t understand the type of event that was taking place in Nelspruit Plaza. Furthermore there were no big banners that were displayed by LGBTIs in order to pass the message clearly to the community.
There were stickers pasted on their bodies. The directions were given by the director of the march pity the crowed couldn’t hear her, as she was using her voice to cascade the information. She had to move up and down to make sure that everybody was moving to the same direction. The Mbombela traffic police were available to control the members of the march.
After standing for hours, we were transported by buses to the show grounds where the event was sceduld to end, after treating the crowed with speeches’ from different representatives and organisations, music, performers and the after party.
I’ve been to three prides, in Mpumalanga I witnessed a very drunk Lesbian who couldn’t do anything because she was too drunk. She was lying down and no one was helping her there was no first aid provided for her, until I decided to help her together with my colleagues and left her with friends that could look after her. I wish the Pride March could invite all the departments especially the Department of Health (DoH) who can take care of the emergencies around the event. The security should be available on the field to resolve any conflict happening in the events.
The nature of the pride uses the same culture usually from international, provincial and local, while the settings depend on the organiser of the event. Durban March was one of a kind. The march was from one point straight to the end point where the whole event was going to be wrapped up. The attendance was also reasonable but I still believe it can be more than that referring to the growing population around Durban.
There are many townships under KwaZulu Natal for an example Umlazi, is the second biggest township in South Africa following Soweto in Johannesburg. And the LGBTI population is really growing fast day by day. Pity we haven’t been able to exercise the Umlazi Pride.
However the purpose of Pride is to increase visibility and public awareness of LGBTI issues, encouraging the individual cultural norms for an example female and male behaviour need to be emphasized. LGBTI need to be well educated about gender and sexual orientation. I personally believe being any kind of LGBTI doesn’t change the fact of the birth gender unless the person has gone through the process of gender change surgery. A female will remain as a female, she is at risk of being a victim of rape, and its even more if she is a lesbian due to hate crime. Alcohol abuse is putting LGBTI lives at risk. Moreover health education concerning safer sex practices is more important and the routine check-ups needs to be emphasized more and more. We need to close all the gaps together as LGBTI for the better.
I thank you for the experience we gained, the knowledge we have explored, the acceptance we have received from all the representatives. Nothing can ever replace the time we have spent together with Mpumalanga LGBTI members. Hope we meet again.
Related link
2014 Aug. 9: A video of the first Mpumalanga Pride